playRyan O’HanlonNov 17, 2026, 05:47 AM ETCloseRyan O’Hanlon is a staff writer for ESPN.com. He’s also the author of “Net Gains: Inside the Beautiful Game’s Analytics Revolution.”Multiple AuthorsOpen Extended ReactionsWe’ve been looking for someone to save American soccer for a long time. Well, men’s soccer, at least.Before the 1998 World Cup, the U.S. Soccer Federation commissioned Project 2010, a 100-plus-page report outlining how the USMNT could win the 2010 World Cup.
The cover image of the report is a picture of an astronaut standing on the moon, with an American flag in one hand, a photoshopped World Cup trophy in his other hand and a soccer ball at his feet. At the top are the words: “WE CAN FLY.”Coauthored by eventual Real Madrid and Portugal manager Carlos Queiroz, the Project 2010 intro begins:”Throughout history, Americans have many times demonstrated a remarkable ability to accomplish extraordinary goals. While Americans do not own a monopoly on inventiveness or problem solving, one fact sets them apart from the rest of the world. America’s collective resources and creativity are the greatest on earth.”The USMNT then finished in last place at the 1998 World Cup and never actually hired Queiroz to implement his 113-page plan.Eight years later, the USSF tried to hire its next savior.
Jurgen Klinsmann said “no” at first but eventually gave in after another half-decade of arm-pulling. The Associated Press made the task quite clear: “Klinsmann’s job is to transform U.S. football.” And here’s how Reuters put it: “As a former World Cup winner, Jurgen Klinsmann knows what it takes to rule the world. The United States has similar ambitions but have not come close to reaching their goals, so they have hired Klinsmann to teach them how.”Five years after he was hired, Klinsmann was fired, and a year beyond that, in 2017, the USMNT failed to qualify for its first World Cup since 1986. Donna Shalala, then a USSF board member tweeted, “Time for a revolution.” You probably remember Taylor Twellman’s assessment on ESPN’s airwaves, too: “What are we doing?
What are we doing?”The calls for revolution led to … a former USMNT player and MLS manager being named the new coach. But once Gregg Berhalter’s side stumbled home out of the group stages at the 2024 Copa America, the urge for an uprising reappeared. As Alexi Lalas outlined in his criteria for the next manager: “We want big, we want bold, and dare I say we want arrogant.”We did get that — for a couple of years, anyway.Mauricio Pochettino was exactly the kind of elite, experienced manager that fans, the federation and former players had been begging for going back nearly 30 years. But now he’s off to Manchester United, so … now what?For perhaps the first time ever, U.S.
Soccer doesn’t need a revolutionary or a savior, or an emperor or a conqueror, or a warlord or a messiah or whatever you want to call it. No, it just needs someone to keep things moving in the same direction that they already are.How the USMNT’s tactics have transformedplay1:44Why now is the right time for Man United and PochettinoThere are two ways the USMNT is going to improve its performance at the World Cup. They’re not unrelated, but they’re still worth separating out.The first: how the team chooses to play. At the broadest level, the best teams tend to do a combination of the following: press high, keep possession under pressure and keep the ball away from their own goal.
This is the dumbed-down model of the version of soccer that Americans have wanted to see their team play one day.Well, the team is playing this way already.We’ll start with pressing. This chart looks at a number I took from the stats app Futi: high defensive actions, or the number of tackles, interceptions, fouls and clearances made in the attacking half.The chart’s a little easier to understand if we take 2010 as the beginning of the “modern” era of the sport, given that tactics were a little more chaotic and less organized before then. But even still: In 2026, the USMNT broke up play in the attacking half more often than in every other tournament on record.Pressing, though, isn’t necessarily the province of possession dominance anymore. No longer are teams mainly pressing just to establish control of the ball.
Just watch any Premier League match these days and you’ll see that there are now all kinds of ways to employ an active, physical press. In other words: Underdogs can press now, too.However, we’ve also seen the USMNT steadily improve its performance against the opposition press. Prior to the 2022 World Cup, the Americans had completed 80% of their passes outside the attacking third only once; they’ve now broken 85% in each of the past two tournaments.This is the standout change in the USMNT; the team is capable of controlling the ball in a way we’ve never seen it do before. Of course, controlling the ball is useless if you’re not getting into the right areas of the field.
Swapping a counterattacking approach for a possession-dominant style isn’t going to make the team better if you’re just passing it around your own penalty area.For this, we can look at field tilt, or the ratio of your final-third possession to your opponent’s final-third possession:While the Americans did keep the ball in buildup play under Klinsmann at the 2014 World Cup, they struggled to get it anywhere valuable. But under Berhalter and then Pochettino, that changed. In each of the previous two tournaments, the majority of the matches were played in the other team’s defensive third, and the ball got there in large part because the team was adept enough in possession to pass it up there.In other words, there has been a revolution. The USMNT already plays like one of the best teams in the world: It presses, passes out of pressure and keeps the ball away from its own goal.Before 2026, none of these things had happened at the same time; before 2022, barely any of them happened at all.
There was absolutely a ceiling to the way that the USMNT used to play, but now the tactical or stylistic blueprint is there: As the players get better, so should the team.How the USMNT player pool has transformedplay3:08What does Pochettino need to change to make Man United successful?The players, of course, are getting better.Just take the best soccer leagues in the world, the ones in England, Spain, Italy, France and Germany. Across those competitions this season, Americans have played nearly 12,000 minutes — the 20th most of any country in the world and the seventh most among countries outside of Europe. Ten seasons ago, the number of American minutes ranked just 41st.It’s no different when you raise the level of competition. For every year prior to 2020-21, there were 48 individual American Champions League or European Cup seasons.
Three Americans appeared in a match in 1999-2000, three more in 2007-08, and when you add all the rest up before 2020-21, you get 48.In the six-plus seasons since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic? That number is all the way up to 62.It’s no different in the other direction, either. In the English second division, the Championship, Americans have played nearly 6,000 minutes already this season — ninth most in the league. Ten years prior, Americans played the 17th-most minutes in the Championship.It doesn’t make sense to apply the same minutes-play logic to MLS.
The broader goal is for the best American players to leave MLS to go play in Europe, but a sign of a healthy development pipeline for a nation outside of the Big Five leagues would be an increase in the number of young players appearing in their domestic league. And, yep, we’ve got that, too:It’s worth noting that this is all happening while the broader talent level in MLS has increased. So, more young Americans have gotten playing time while the competition for playing time is more intense than ever before. And that’s because these kids aren’t just good for their age in MLS; no, they’re good for MLS — period.Cav















Leave a Reply