playGabriele MarcottiNov 17, 2026, 03:56 AM ETCloseGabriele Marcotti is a senior soccer writer for ESPN.com. Read his archive here and follow him on Twitter: @Marcotti.Multiple AuthorsOpen Extended ReactionsIf Manchester United were “Sesame Street” and this season (and the next one) are to have a happy — or, at least, not horrible — ending, the Word of the Day has to be C-H-A-N-G-E.As in, change the top-down culture at the club.Guess what? Mauricio Pochettino isn’t going to do that. It’s above his pay grade, he usually doesn’t stick around long enough — his average tenure in his past three gigs is 18 months — and it’s not clear at all that his assertive, micromanaging approach is what United need. (It bears repeating, again, that what worked for Sir Alex Ferguson — an outlier from a different era — might not work today.)What Pochettino can do effectively is galvanize the fanbase, restore enthusiasm to the team — a low bar after Michael Carrick’s latter hangdog outings — help improve individual players and, in the short term, push United back up the Premier League table.
As tempting as it might be to gnash teeth and pull hair Old Testament style, the UEFA Champions League spots are eight points away and there are 28 matches left to play. Meanwhile in Europe, the club seems headed to the UCL knockout playoffs, which offers at least a shot at advancement.- Who should be the USMNT’s coaching candidates to succeed Pochettino? – Man United, Pochettino’s to-do list based on what’s gone wrong this season – Meet Como’s Nico Paz, the heir to Lionel Messi’s Argentina No. 10 shirtWhat Pochettino can’t do, however, is fix the club. That has to come from a review at the very top, an analysis of decisions that were made, who made them, why they worked or did not work, what can be learned from them, and who should be held accountable and how.It’s pretty basic stuff at most successful organizations, but for whatever reason, it’s not something United have been good at doing for a very long time. And it matters because most clubs that succeed over time have strong, effective corporate and sporting cultures that go beyond the head coach, which means that if he moves on, it doesn’t lead to Armageddon.The early indications that this will happen aren’t great.
In September, Avram Glazer (the one with the bald man’s ponytail) told an audience of investors that Manchester United aren’t dependent on sporting success to retain their commercial oomph and global brand. He then cited the New York Yankees, who last won the World Series in 2009, and the Dallas Cowboys, who haven’t advanced past the divisional round of the NFL playoffs in more than 40 years.We can debate to what degree it’s true of United in their sport. Certainly, the fact that they’ve made a loss in each of the past seven seasons (a spell that saw them win just two domestic cups) and the fact that top football clubs derive a third (if not more) of their revenue from prize money would suggest otherwise. What we can’t debate is that it was a silly and tone-deaf thing to say.Then there’s Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the INEOS gang.
Other than working on the new stadium — something on which we need to withhold judgment until it actually happens — it’s hard to see what value add he has provided the club. In the 33 months since the weird deal in which he took over “football operations” (in exchange for his $1.65 billion purchase of 28.9% of the shares), United have won 35 of 99 Premier League games and are now on their fourth manager.Ratcliffe has spent more than $35 million (more than a million dollars per month, for those keeping score at home) of the club’s money purely in payouts to coaches and sporting directors he has fired. (The figure would be closer to $50 million if AC Milan hadn’t kindly offered Ruben Amorim a job just a few months after his sacking.) One of those he sacked, sporting director Dan Ashworth, was in charge for just five months before Ratcliffe decided he didn’t like him.Ratcliffe also hired Omar Berrada from Manchester City as chief executive. I’m not going to argue Berrada’s merits, but he was hired when the club knew City were under investigation by the Premier League for a whole raft of very serious charges including false accounting, breaching financial rules and paying people off the books. Sure enough, Man City were found guilty in September.
Berrada spent 13 years at City, including time as chief operating officer, commercial director and director of partnership sales, which means he was in the thick of it. City are appealing the verdict, but did it not occur to Ratcliffe that Berrada might get caught up in the City case and, possibly, face further individual charges? Why take the risk?Then there’s Jason Wilcox, the current sporting director. He’s another City alum, spending years coaching in their academy before joining Southampton in January 2023, getting relegated six months later and then leaving them 15 months after that to join United.
He draws fire because of United’s transfer activity. It’s fair criticism and the buck does stop with him, but it’s worth remembering every deal is different and at most clubs, it isn’t a case of one recruitment guy making decisions single-handedly.play0:36Pochettino reveals some of his coaching staff have already flown to ManchesterThe logical thing to do here is audit and vet Wilcox’s every move. How much of Player X’s signing was down to the coach’s preference? Why did we miss out on Player Y?
Could we have negotiated a better deal for Player Z?Unlike his peers elsewhere, especially on the continent, Wilcox never speaks in public, save for the odd appearance on in-house media. It’s probably not ideal in terms of messaging, and as a result we really don’t know how responsible he is for the successes and (more frequently) failures of the club’s transfers. Internally, United do know how responsible he is, and it’s critical that they assess and hold him accountable, for better and for worse.The same applies for others, such as performance director Sam Erith and chief scout Kyle Macaulay. You can look from the outside — as fans and media do — note United’s poor physical stats and mounting injury list in Erith’s case, or the dud signings in Macaulay’s case, and conclude they’re doing a bad job.
But Erith has a fancy résumé that includes a decade at City and a couple of years with the New York Knicks and New York Rangers. Macauley has a big reputation for the work he did at Brighton & Hove Albion, the gold standard club when it comes to recruitment in England.The obvious questions that we don’t know, but that United should try to answer: Were they empowered to their jobs? How big a part of the bad decisions were they? Can we put them in better positions to succeed?The operative word here is “accountability,” and the risk, without mincing words, is that if Ratcliffe hired Berrada and Berrada brought in all these characters, it’s unclear whether they are going to be able to assess them properly.
You’d hope so, but if not, it’s time for the Glazers — the guys who ultimately pay the bills — to figure this out. Without it, there’s only so much Pochettino can do.The Old Trafford spin machine is presenting the new manager as cut from the same cloth as Sir Alex in terms of being some sort of all-controlling boss. Yet Pochettino has in fact done his best work at a big club — the early years at Tottenham Hotspur — when he had a strong and present owner (Daniel Levy) who was in his face every day. He’d do well to remember that, just as he’d do well to remember that his past two big clubs (Chelsea and Paris Saint-Germain) did better after he left.Manchester United needs a culture change — one of accountability and responsibility, with the requisite accompanying messaging.
Pochettino can impact the first team, but he can’t change the entire club. (Nor do you necessarily want him to be the guy doing it.)Bringing him in is a baby step; now it’s time for the














Leave a Reply