playBill BarnwellNov 16, 2026, 08:25 AM ETCloseBill Barnwell is a senior NFL writer for ESPN.com. He analyzes football on and off the field like no one else on the planet, writing about in-season X’s and O’s, offseason transactions and so much more. He is the host of the Bill Barnwell Show podcast, with episodes released weekly. Barnwell joined ESPN in 2011 as a staff writer at Grantland.Multiple AuthorsOpen Extended ReactionsIf the trade deadline marks the beginning of the NFL’s stretch run, there are four teams that might already be pulling up lame.
In the first game after the deadline, with rosters essentially locked for the remainder of 2026, four franchises that were already facing difficult paths forward to the postseason looked overmatched in Week 10 losses.The Cowboys, Patriots, Raiders and Texans all lost in Week 10, and while they each had serious playoff aspirations at one point or another this season. none of the four is currently a favorite to make it into the 14-team field, per ESPN’s Football Power Index.Subscribe: ‘The Bill Barnwell Show’They’re collectively down … but are they out? I’ll start in Big D, where the Cowboys spent most of the day chasing shadows on and off the field.Note: All playoff chance percentages are via ESPN’s Football Power Index.Jump to: Cowboys | Patriots | Raiders | TexansDallas Cowboys (4-6)Peak playoff probability in 2026: 82.1% (after Week 4) Current playoff probability: 42.1% Week 10: Lost 46-40 to 49ersThe Cowboys allowed the 49ers to rack up 584 yards, the most they’ve allowed in a home game in the 67-year history of the franchise. And if there’s a play that will come to stand as the example of how badly things have gone wrong for the Cowboys on defense since the ill-fated decision to trade Micah Parsons to the Packers, it would be the 66-yard Christian McCaffrey touchdown that essentially sealed up the game with 3:23 to go.Under first-year defensive coordinator Christian Parker, the Cowboys have not been a blitz-happy team. They blitz at the league’s third-lowest rate, in part to protect a shaky secondary and in part to align with the Vic Fangio-style defense that the Cowboys chose to install as they hired Parker, two years after it was at its peak.
They still manage to get pressure at a top-10 rate, but when the Cowboys don’t get home, they have the second-worst pass defense in the NFL by Total QBR.Quarterback Brock Purdy had sliced the Cowboys blitz apart when Parker did send extra rushers to this point, going 5-of-5 for 131 yards with a touchdown, but also took two sacks on seven dropbacks. Blitzing turned the game into a boom-or-serious-bust situation for the Cowboys. Most defenses would prefer to major in what they do best with the game on the line, but with the 49ers averaging more than 7 yards per play with a 50% success rate when the Cowboys didn’t blitz Sunday, Parker must have felt like he needed to throw a changeup to have any hope of stopping them.So, facing a second-and-10 situation after a George Kittle false start, Parker sent the house. The Cowboys sent six defenders, twisting their three down linemen and blitzing an extra rusher to the weak side of the line, hoping that the pass rush would get home and force Purdy off his spot.
Even if it didn’t work, the blitz might push McCaffrey to come across the formation to try to block the free rusher, taking a key receiver out of the progression for the 49ers.That didn’t happen. McCaffrey immediately released vertically out of the backfield. The defender responsible for him was the edge rusher on that side of the field, who dropped off the line as a product of the Cowboys overloading the weakside rush to leave them with five coverage defenders against five eligible receivers. And that’s how the Cowboys ended up with 37-year-old Von Miller in man-to-man coverage against the best receiving back in football with the game on the line.It wasn’t much of a contest, although Miller did manage to hit 18.5 mph as he tried to chase down McCaffrey, the first time he has reached that speed on a single snap since 2021, according to NFL Next Gen Stats.
This was probably the easiest catch and run of McCaffrey’s career and his second long touchdown reception of the game, having turned a catch against a blown coverage on a scramble drill into a 74-yard score earlier in the contest (two linebackers had attempted to chase down Purdy and neither ran with McCaffrey). It was the third touchdown of 60 or more yards the Cowboys had allowed in the game, too, marking the first time a defense has allowed three of those in a single contest since October 2007.It’s too simplistic to blame Miller, who should never be expected to hold up in man coverage against McCaffrey. It’s not as simple as blaming Parker, who dialed up the sort of exotic pressure that other teams have pulled out in key situations for stops. It’s just the reality of what happens in Dallas.
Since this team traded Parsons, the Cowboys have spent the past 27 games throwing stuff at the wall on defense and hoping something sticks.That’s how you end up with Miller, an edge rusher at the very end of his career and nearly a half-decade removed from his last season as a full-time starter, with the game on the line needing a stop. It’s how you end up with Parker sending an all-out blitz despite the 49ers picking those blitzes apart for most of the game, in the hopes of fooling one of the league’s best offensive coaches. It’s how you end up with Parker, as the Cowboys followed a disastrous year with an experienced-but-uninspiring defensive coordinator in Matt Eberflus by hiring what they hoped would be the league’s next exciting young defensive mind.play0:24Christian McCaffrey breaks free for his third TD of the gameAnd trying to chase down the problems with their defense, the Cowboys and Jerry Jones have desperately made personnel decision after personnel decision. They traded first- and second-round picks to the Jets for Quinnen Williams, and while he has been very good during his time in Dallas, he hasn’t been able to singlehandedly fix the defense.
It seemed like a microcosm when Williams literally ripped the ball out of Kaelon Black’s hands to try to force a game-altering fumble on San Francisco’s next and final possession, only for the 49ers running back to fall on the football before any of Williams’ teammates could react.The Cowboys have traded for Kenny Clark, Rashan Gary, Joey Porter Jr. and Dee Winters. They used first-round picks on Caleb Downs and Malachi Lawrence. They signed Cobie Durant and Jalen Thompson in free agency. None of those moves is egregious in a vacuum.
In the big picture, though, there’s no identity, no coherent plan and no short- or long-term vision. The Cowboys traded Parsons because they wanted to save money and spread the cash and draft capital around the roster, then traded most of that capital away to land Williams, who signed a massive extension. They’re spending $182.2 million in cash on their defense this season, the fifth most of any team in the league, so they aren’t saving anything by the decision to move on from Parsons. They look and operate like an organization that desperately wants something to work on defense but has no idea how to make it happen.And so, while wildly chasing down solutions on defense as a personnel philosophy, the Cowboys do the same thing on the field.
Deebo Samuel Sr.’s 70-yard touchdown on an end-around was one of the most dramatic collective overpursuits you’ll ever see on a single snap, as Samuel was expected to gain 35 yards from the moment he touched the ball by the Next Gen Stats model, the most by any runner on any play since 2022.It’s one thing to get fooled on misdirection, but edge rusher James Houston and defensive tackle Elijah Garcia were the two down linemen on the backside of the play who might have forced Samuel back to their help or at least slowed down the hybrid receiver. Instead, after Samuel takes the pitch, Houston and Garcia e









Leave a Reply