⚾ Every MLB team's likelihood of signing Tarik Skubal

playDavid SchoenfieldNov 16, 2026, 07:00 AM ETCloseCovers MLB for ESPN.com Former deputy editor of Page 2 Been with ESPN.com since 1995Multiple AuthorsOpen Extended ReactionsTarik Skubal is the golden ticket in the 2026-27 MLB free agent class. In what is viewed as a weak group of free agents, the two-time Cy Young Award winner is the clear difference-maker, a pitcher with a 2.42 ERA over the past three seasons.The state of modern pitching is at an interesting inflection. While starters are throwing harder than ever — with even more unhittable breaking balls and a wider variety of pitches — it is also arguably harder than ever to fill 162 starts in a season, let alone fill enough quality innings. In 2026, 377 different pitchers started a game — an average of 12.6 per team — and Michael Wacha was the only pitcher to throw 200 innings.Ten years ago, there were 310 different pitchers who started a game and 15 pitchers who reached 200 innings.

Twenty years ago, those figures were 303 starters and 45 who reached 200 innings. Forty years ago, it was 9.6 starters per team and 52 who pitched 200 innings — and a total of 82 who pitched 162 innings compared to just 46 in 2026.You get the idea: An ace starter on Skubal’s level is a special addition to any roster. Of course, with Skubal perhaps in line for a $300 million contract, not every team has the same odds of signing him — although, who knows, a new labor deal could drastically change how these deals unfold.With that, let’s introduce the Skubal Tiers — breaking all 30 teams into tiers on their likelihood of landing Skubal. And since every team needs pitching help of some sort, we’ll include a reasonable backup pitching plan for each team.Note: References to projected contracts are from Kiley McDaniel’s ranking of the top 50 free agents, while references to a team’s payroll are drawn from the roster resource section at FanGraphs.The teams in this tier are mostly the ones you would expect: the so-called small-market teams with owners unwilling to spend big in free agency (despite San Diego having proved a higher-spending approach is possible).

Even a new system with a salary floor is unlikely to change habits overnight, so we’ll go straight to the backup pitching plans for these teams.30. Colorado RockiesBackup plan: Zac Gallen. It’s not that the Rockies never sign free agent starters — heck, just last year they signed Jose Quintana, Tomoyuki Sugano and Michael Lorenzen — it’s just that they haven’t signed a premium free agent starter since Mike Hampton in 2001 (at $121 million, that remains the second-biggest free agent contract in Rockies history). Those veterans last offseason were all signed to one-year deals, so the Rockies are basically in the same situation, looking to fill out a rotation with pitchers that no other team really wants.29.

AthleticsBackup plan: Shota Imanaga. Back in 1993 — let’s see, that was 33 years ago — the A’s re-signed free agents Mark McGwire and Ruben Sierra to identical five-year, $28 million contracts. The 1993 A’s proceeded to go 68-94, and maybe that scared them off forever from signing top-tier free agents. Believe it or not, the A’s have since signed only two free agents to bigger contracts: Billy Butler for $30 million in 2015 and Luis Severino for $67 million in 2025.

That’s the long way of saying Skubal is not going to West Sacramento. But Imanaga fits the Severino mold of overpaying for a mid-rotation starter.28. Cincinnati RedsBackup plan: Kris Bubic/Dustin May. The Reds need a starter to replace Hunter Greene, who will miss the entire season after Tommy John surgery, but the top 10 highest free agent contracts in franchise history don’t even add up to Skubal’s projected $352 million contract.

To the Reds’ credit, they did at least sign Chase Burns to a $105 million extension. They can dip into the less expensive tier of starters like Bubic (projected deal of two years, $18 million) or May (one year, $14 million).27. Miami MarlinsBackup plan: Raisel Iglesias. Since Bruce Sherman bought the team in 2017, the most the Marlins have paid for a free agent is Jorge Soler’s $36 million deal — so, no, Skubal isn’t taking his talents to Little Havana, South Beach, Coral Gables, Key Biscayne, Fort Lauderdale or anywhere else in South Florida.

The Marlins were middle of the pack in both rotation ERA and bullpen ERA, but will need a closer to replace Pete Fairbanks, so that’s probably a priority over a starter (assuming they don’t trade Sandy Alcantara and open up a hole). Iglesias is doable on a one-year, $14 million deal.26. Kansas City RoyalsBackup plan: Chris Bassitt/Kevin Gausman. The Royals dug into the pitching market back in 2024, signing Michael Wacha and Seth Lugo — and the pair helped them win a wild card that season.

Both even later signed extensions, and Wacha was the only pitcher in the majors to reach 200 innings in 2026. The Royals do need rotation help after ranking 25th in ERA, and Bassitt is the kind of low-cost vet they can get on a one-year deal. If they want to get more aggressive, Gausman has better strikeout stuff than Bassitt, and his projected three-year, $51 million deal won’t break the payroll.25. Minnesota TwinsBackup plan: Steven Okert/Jason Adam.

To improve on a rotation that ranked 22nd in ERA, the Twins will hope Pablo Lopez is ready after missing all of 2026 due to Tommy John surgery. A rotation with Lopez, Joe Ryan, Taj Bradley, Dean Kremer and the Bailey Ober/Zebby Matthews/Connor Prielipp group has promise and depth. If anything, the Twins might trade one of Ryan, Kremer or Ober, who are all in their final season before free agency. In the meantime, Minnesota’s offseason pitching focus will be the bullpen, which it avoided addressing last offseason.24.

Cleveland GuardiansBackup plan: Casey Mize. The Guardians return their five regular starters from 2026, but might still look to upgrade the back of the rotation — and perhaps look to trade Tanner Bibee. The five-year, $48 million contract Bibee signed a few years ago starts ramping up in cost, as he’s due $7.4 million in 2027, $10.4 million in 2028 and $21.4 million in 2029. The Guardians traded infielder Andres Gimenez when his deal reached this point, so a similar decision could be made with Bibee.

Mize could be a great add-low move after he struggled the final two months with the Padres.23. Houston AstrosBackup plan: Nick Martinez/Nick Pivetta. Skubal to the Astros? That would be like signing up for Napoleon’s army right before the Battle of Waterloo.

If the Astros are going to give $300 million to anyone, it will be with an extension for 2026 AL MVP Yordan Alvarez, not a free agent from another team (the biggest free agent contract since Jim Crane bought the team has been Josh Hader’s $95 million deal). That said, the rotation was a mess, finishing 27th in ERA and last in walk rate. New general manager Randy Flores has a tough task to improve this pitching staff, but given the walk problems, adding a strike-thrower like Martinez or Pivetta is the way to go.22. Pittsburgh PiratesThe owners’ latest salary cap proposal included a salary floor of $180.2 million.

The Pirates’ payroll currently sits at an estimated $129 million after finishing 2026 at $109 million. So, umm, the Pirates could maybe afford Skubal in a different world than currently exists and can dream of a 1-2 duo of Skubal and Paul Skenes.Backup plan: David Peterson/Erick Fedde. The rotation has the potential to improve significantly from last year’s No. 14 ranking in ERA — especially Skenes and Bubba Chandler, who had a promising if erratic rookie season. Mitch Keller is coming off a shoulder injury and a 5.29 ERA, but he’s signed for two more years, so Pittsburgh isn’t going to be eager to push him out.

Still, adding a veteran swingman/sixth starter seems prudent.21. Los Angeles AngelsWith Stan Kroenke coming on as the new owner — the sale won’t be officially approved until January — maybe there will be a ne

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *